Antonio Melani Carolie Espadrille Platform Wedge Fisherman Sandals

When it comes to summer footwear, I’ve always been on a quest for that perfect blend of style, comfort, and versatility. After years of disappointing purchases that either looked good but felt terrible or were comfortable but visually underwhelming, I finally struck gold with the Antonio Melani Carolie Espadrille Platform Wedge Fisherman Sandals. These beauties have completely transformed my warm-weather wardrobe, and I’m excited to share my comprehensive experience with you all.

Let me tell you, finding the right summer sandal is no small feat (pun intended!). As someone who values both fashion and function, I’ve spent countless hours researching, trying on, and sadly returning sandals that just didn’t make the cut. But these Carolie sandals? They’ve become my go-to footwear for everything from casual beach days to semi-formal summer events. And I’m not exaggerating when I say they’ve earned compliments everywhere I go!

In this guide, I’ll walk you through everything you need to know about these remarkable sandals—from where to buy them to how they fit, what makes them special, and how to style them for various occasions. Whether you’re a longtime fan of the Antonio Melani brand or just discovering them now, this detailed buying guide will help you decide if the Carolie sandals deserve a spot in your closet (spoiler alert: they absolutely do!).

Where to Find Your Perfect Pair

Let’s start with the most pressing question: where can you actually get your hands on these coveted sandals? The Antonio Melani Carolie Espadrille Platform Wedge Fisherman Sandals are primarily available at Dillard’s, both in their brick-and-mortar stores and on their website. As an exclusive Antonio Melani retailer, Dillard’s typically carries the full range of colors and sizes.

I initially discovered mine during a spontaneous shopping trip to my local Dillard’s. I wasn’t even looking for sandals that day, but they caught my eye from across the shoe department, and it was love at first sight! The advantage of shopping in-store is that you can try them on before committing, which I highly recommend for any footwear purchase.

If you prefer online shopping, the Dillard’s website regularly stocks these sandals, particularly at the beginning of the spring/summer season. I’ve noticed they tend to sell out of popular sizes by mid-summer, so if you’re eyeing a pair, I wouldn’t wait too long! The website often features helpful customer reviews and multiple product images that give you a good feel for the sandals from different angles.

For those looking for potential discounts, I’ve occasionally spotted the Carolie sandals during Dillard’s seasonal sales, particularly their end-of-summer clearance events. However, since these are such a popular style, they don’t often make it to the deep discount phase. I’ve also seen them pop up on resale platforms like Poshmark and Mercari, which can be a great option if you’re looking for a gently used pair at a lower price point.

The Key Features That Make Carolie Sandals Stand Out

What exactly makes these sandals so special? Let me break down the key features that have turned me into such a devoted fan.

First and foremost, the distinctive fisherman-style strappy design gives these sandals a timeless yet contemporary look. Unlike traditional fisherman sandals that sit flat against the ground, the Carolie elevates this classic style with a modern twist—quite literally! The woven design encases your foot in a way that feels secure yet breezy, perfect for warm weather.

The platform espadrille wedge is arguably the star feature of these sandals. With approximately a 3.5-inch heel height and a 1-inch platform, they give you a significant height boost without the discomfort of a traditional high heel. The espadrille portion is beautifully crafted with visible stitching that adds a handcrafted, artisanal touch. This design element immediately evokes vacation vibes, whether you’re actually on a Mediterranean getaway or just running errands in your neighborhood.

Another standout feature is the leather upper construction. Antonio Melani doesn’t cut corners on quality, and it shows in the buttery-soft leather that forms the sandal’s upper portion. The leather is substantial enough to provide structure but supple enough to mold to your foot over time, creating a custom-like fit after just a few wears.

The cushioned footbed deserves special mention too. It’s lightly padded with a smooth, breathable lining that prevents the dreaded summer foot sweat that can make other sandals slippery and uncomfortable. I’ve found that even after hours of wear, my feet don’t slide around inside these sandals, which is a common problem with many summer shoes.

Finally, the rubber outsole provides excellent traction, which is crucial for a platform sandal. I’ve confidently worn mine on various surfaces, from slick marble floors to grassy lawns, without any stability issues. The outsole also adds to the durability of the sandals, showing minimal wear even after multiple seasons of use.

Comfort: Can You Really Wear Them All Day?

I know what you’re thinking—sure, they look good, but can you actually wear platform wedges comfortably for more than an hour? The answer, somewhat surprisingly, is a resounding yes! The Antonio Melani Carolie sandals offer exceptional all-day comfort, something I honestly didn’t expect when I first purchased them.

During my first wear, I took them to an outdoor wedding that involved a ceremony on grass, cocktail hour on a patio, and reception dancing that lasted well into the night. I was fully prepared to switch to the emergency flats I had stashed in my purse, but remarkably, I never needed them. Sure, by the very end of the night my feet were ready for a break, but I didn’t experience any of the usual pressure points, blisters, or aching arches that typically come with wearing elevated shoes for extended periods.

What makes them so comfortable? It’s a combination of thoughtful design elements. The platform at the front of the sandal decreases the effective heel height, reducing strain on the ball of your foot. The wedge design distributes your weight more evenly than a stiletto would, preventing that painful pressure that builds up when your weight is concentrated in small areas.

The strappy fisherman design also plays a role in the comfort factor. Unlike sandals with just one or two straps that can dig into your skin, the multiple leather straps of the Carolie disperse pressure across the top of your foot. This design also keeps your foot securely in place, preventing the forward sliding that often causes toe pain in wedges and heels.

That said, comfort is subjective, and if you have specific foot issues like severe plantar fasciitis or bunions, you might have a different experience. I have fairly average feet with medium arches, and for me, these rank among the most comfortable elevated sandals I’ve ever owned. I’ve worn them for full 8-hour days of standing and walking with minimal discomfort—something I can’t say for most of my dressier shoes.

Finding Your Perfect Fit

Fit is perhaps the most critical factor when purchasing any footwear, and the Carolie sandals have some specific characteristics worth knowing about. Based on my experience and what I’ve gathered from other wearers, these sandals tend to run true to size for most people.

I typically wear a size 8 in most brands, occasionally sizing up to an 8.5 for closed-toe shoes, and the size 8 in the Carolie fits me perfectly. There’s just enough room in the toe box to prevent any uncomfortable pressure, while the heel cup cradles my heel without any slipping or gapping.

The fisherman style with its multiple adjustable straps accommodates a variety of foot widths, which is one of its greatest advantages. While Antonio Melani doesn’t explicitly offer wide sizes in this model, the design naturally works well for slightly wider feet. If you have very narrow feet, you might find that you need to tighten the ankle strap to its smallest setting to get a secure fit.

One fit consideration to keep in mind is the height of your instep. If you have a high instep (the arched middle portion of the top of your foot), you might feel some pressure from the straps that cross over this area. The leather does stretch and conform with wear, but it’s something to be aware of when first trying them on.

As for breaking them in, I found that my Carolie sandals required minimal break-in time. The leather is soft enough that it begins molding to your foot almost immediately. I did notice that the ankle strap softened considerably after about 2-3 wears, becoming more comfortable around my ankle bone. If you do experience any stiffness initially, wearing them around the house with socks for an hour or two can help speed up the break-in process.

Material Matters: What Are They Made Of?

The quality of materials used in a shoe directly impacts its comfort, durability, and overall value, and the Antonio Melani Carolie sandals showcase premium materials throughout their construction.

The upper portion is crafted from genuine leather, which explains both the higher price point and the exceptional comfort these sandals provide. Leather is ideal for summer footwear because it’s breathable, molds to your foot shape, and tends to cause fewer blisters than synthetic materials. The leather used in the Carolie has a slight texture that adds visual interest while being practical—minor scuffs don’t show as readily as they would on completely smooth leather.

The distinctive espadrille wedge combines traditional and modern materials. The wrapped portion has the classic jute rope appearance that’s characteristic of espadrille styles, creating that coveted summer aesthetic. However, Antonio Melani has reinforced this with more durable materials beneath the surface, addressing the common issue of rapid deterioration that affects many espadrille shoes.

The footbed features a cushioned synthetic lining that’s both comfortable against bare feet and durable enough to withstand summer heat and moisture. It has enough padding to absorb impact when walking but isn’t so squishy that you lose stability—a delicate balance that many platform shoes fail to achieve.

The outsole is made from a textured rubber material that provides reliable traction even on slippery surfaces. This is particularly important for platform styles, as the last thing you want is to feel unsteady when you’re elevated several inches off the ground! The rubber also adds to the overall durability of the sandals, protecting the more delicate espadrille components from wear and tear.

All hardware, including the buckle on the ankle strap, appears to be high-quality metal with a finish that matches the overall aesthetic of the sandals. In my experience, this hardware has maintained its appearance without tarnishing or discoloring, even with exposure to sweat and sunscreen—common summertime elements that can affect metal components in shoes.

Versatility: From Casual Days to Special Occasions

One of the aspects I love most about the Carolie sandals is their remarkable versatility. They effortlessly span the spectrum from casual to dressy, making them an incredibly practical addition to any summer wardrobe.

For casual everyday wear, I frequently pair my Carolies with simple jeans and a t-shirt or tank top. The elevated platform instantly makes even the most basic outfit look more put-together, while the classic fisherman design keeps things from feeling too formal. They’re perfect for weekend brunches, casual shopping trips, or coffee dates where you want to look stylish without seeming like you tried too hard.

These sandals also excel in the smart casual category. I’ve worn mine to numerous office events during summer months with cropped dress pants and a lightweight blazer. The espadrille element adds a seasonal appropriateness that makes them suitable for professional settings with a more relaxed dress code. They’re particularly perfect for outdoor work functions where stilettos would sink into grass or be uncomfortable on uneven surfaces.

Surprisingly, the Carolie sandals can also hold their own for semi-formal occasions. For summer weddings, garden parties, or nice dinners, I’ve paired them with sundresses, maxi dresses, and even jumpsuits. The substantial platform and quality materials give them a dressiness that belies their comfortable design. I’ve received numerous compliments when wearing them to events where others are hobbling around in less comfortable formal footwear!

As for summer vacations, these sandals have become my must-pack footwear. On a recent trip to Southern Europe, I wore them nearly every day—for exploring cobblestone streets during the day and transitioning to evening dinners without needing to change. Their versatility meant I could pack significantly fewer shoes, leaving room in my suitcase for souvenirs!

Styling Tips: What to Wear with Carolie Sandals

One of the greatest strengths of these sandals is how effortlessly they pair with virtually any summer outfit. Let me share some of my favorite styling combinations that have worked beautifully with the Carolie sandals.

Dresses and Skirts: The Carolie sandals add the perfect height to summer dresses of all lengths. With midi dresses, they create a balanced silhouette that elongates the leg. For maxi dresses, the platform gives you needed height to prevent the hem from dragging. I particularly love pairing them with flowy sundresses for a bohemian-inspired look that feels both casual and refined.

Cropped Pants and Jeans: The platform wedge works wonderfully with cropped pants or jeans, creating a lengthening effect for the ankle area. Wide-leg cropped pants paired with these sandals has become my go-to summer office look—professional but seasonally appropriate. For more casual days, the Carolies elevate simple cropped jeans and a tucked-in tee to a more intentional-looking outfit.

Shorts: While some platform wedges can look overwhelming with shorts, the fisherman-style straps of the Carolie create enough visual interest to balance the look. I like pairing mine with slightly longer bermuda or paper-bag style shorts rather than very short cuts, which creates a more proportional silhouette.

Beach Attire: Unlike many style-forward sandals, the Carolies actually work well with beach cover-ups and casual resort wear. The espadrille element feels natural in these settings, and they’re stable enough to walk on boardwalks and beach paths. They instantly elevate a simple swimsuit and cover-up combination to something more put-together for beachside dining.

Jumpsuits and Rompers: The Carolie sandals provide the perfect foundational piece for one-piece outfits like jumpsuits and rompers. They add height without competing with the statement nature of these garments. I find that the architectural quality of the sandal’s design complements the structured look of most jumpsuits beautifully.

In terms of colors, the neutral shades that the Carolies come in (more on color options below) make them incredibly versatile. They can serve as either a complementary neutral or a subtle contrast depending on your outfit’s palette. This adaptability is another reason why these sandals have become such a wardrobe workhorse for me.

Color Options: Which Shade is Right for You?

The Antonio Melani Carolie sandals come in several classic colors that offer something for every style preference and wardrobe need. While availability may vary by season and retailer inventory, these are the main color options I’ve seen:

Classic Black: This is the color I initially purchased, and it’s proven to be incredibly versatile. The black leather pairs with everything in my wardrobe and has a slightly dressier feel than some of the other colors. If you’re only going to invest in one pair, black offers maximum versatility for both day and evening wear.

Rich Cognac/Tan: This warm brown leather shade has a beautiful natural look that pairs wonderfully with summer’s lighter color palettes. It has a slightly more casual, earthy vibe than the black and looks especially stunning against both pale and deeper skin tones. This shade also shows the detailed craftsmanship of the espadrille portion particularly well.

Soft Nude/Beige: For those seeking a leg-lengthening effect, the nude option creates a seamless look that makes your legs appear longer. This shade works beautifully with summer whites and pastels and has become increasingly popular for wedding guest attire as it doesn’t compete with more colorful outfits.

Navy Blue: Less commonly available but worth searching for if you wear a lot of blue tones, the navy version offers a fresh alternative to black while maintaining versatility. It pairs beautifully with white summer clothing and creates a classic nautical look when styled with stripes.

Seasonal Colors: Occasionally, Antonio Melani releases the Carolie in limited seasonal colors. I’ve seen them in a gorgeous red and a soft sage green in past seasons. These special editions tend to sell out quickly, so if you spot a limited color you love, I’d recommend purchasing promptly.

When choosing your color, consider not only what would coordinate with most items in your wardrobe but also your lifestyle. If you tend to wear them primarily for dressier occasions, black or nude might serve you best. For casual everyday wear, the cognac shade offers a relaxed versatility. I personally find having both a black pair and a cognac pair covers virtually all my summer footwear needs!

Care and Maintenance: Keeping Your Carolies Looking Fresh

Proper care will significantly extend the life of your Antonio Melani Carolie sandals, allowing you to enjoy them for multiple seasons. Based on my experience maintaining mine for several years, here are my recommended care practices:

Preventative Treatment: Before wearing your sandals for the first time, I highly recommend applying a leather protector spray designed for footwear. This creates a barrier against moisture, dirt, and stains without changing the appearance of the leather. I reapply this every few months during heavy wear seasons.

Regular Cleaning: For routine maintenance, wiping the leather portions with a slightly damp cloth removes surface dust and prevents buildup in the crevices between straps. Allow them to air dry completely away from direct heat or sunlight, which can damage both the leather and espadrille materials.

Deep Cleaning: For more thorough cleaning, I use a gentle leather cleaner specifically formulated for shoes. Apply it with a soft cloth using circular motions, then wipe away with a clean, damp cloth. Avoid soaking the espadrille portion, as excessive moisture can damage the jute material and potentially compromise the structural integrity of the wedge.

Addressing Scuffs: Minor scuffs on the leather can often be buffed out using a leather conditioning cream in a matching color. Apply a small amount with your finger, allow it to absorb, then buff gently with a soft cloth. For the espadrille portion, a soft brush can help remove dirt without damaging the woven texture.

Storage: When not in use, store your Carolie sandals in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. I keep mine in their original box with tissue paper stuffed inside to help them maintain their shape. Alternatively, a shoe bag works well for protection. Avoid stacking heavy items on top of them, which can deform the wedge heel over time.

Sole Maintenance: The rubber outsole is quite durable, but if you notice significant wear, a cobbler can often replace or repair it for far less than the cost of new sandals. This is particularly worthwhile if the upper portion is still in good condition.

Buckle Care: If the metal buckle begins to tarnish, a gentle wipe with a jewelry polishing cloth can restore its shine without damaging the surrounding leather.

With proper care, I’ve found that the Carolie sandals maintain their appearance remarkably well. Mine have endured three summers of regular wear and still look presentable enough for all but the most formal occasions. The quality materials and construction make them responsive to maintenance efforts, which is another reason they represent a good investment despite their higher initial price point.

Who Are These Sandals For? Ideal Users and Limitations

While I’ve sung the praises of the Antonio Melani Carolie sandals throughout this guide, they may not be the perfect choice for everyone. Let’s look at who might love these sandals and who might want to consider alternatives.

These sandals are ideal for:

• Women looking for a versatile summer shoe that works for multiple occasions
• Those who want the height of a heel with significantly more comfort and stability
• People with average to slightly wide feet who appreciate adjustable straps
• Fashion-conscious individuals who value both style and function
• Anyone willing to invest in quality footwear that will last multiple seasons
• Those who walk primarily on paved surfaces, indoor environments, or maintained outdoor areas

The Carolie sandals might not be the best choice for:

• Women with very narrow feet, as the fisherman style may feel too roomy
• Those with significant foot issues like severe plantar fasciitis or pronounced bunions
• People looking for a truly casual, beachy sandal for rough terrain or water activities
• Individuals who prefer completely flat shoes for health or comfort reasons
• Those seeking a highly trendy, season-specific design rather than a classic style

In terms of activity level, I find these sandals comfortable for moderate walking and standing, such as shopping trips, dinner outings, or work environments. While I’ve successfully worn mine for days that involved several miles of walking, they wouldn’t be my first choice for extensive sightseeing on foot or for activities that involve uneven terrain or excessive moisture.

Age-wise, these sandals have a broad appeal. The classic design elements make them appropriate for women from their twenties through their sixties and beyond, while the contemporary platform twist keeps them from feeling matronly. I’ve noticed women of various age groups wearing similar styles, each styling them to suit their personal aesthetic.

The Antonio Melani Carolie vs. Other Fisherman Sandals

The fisherman sandal trend has seen a significant revival in recent years, with options available at virtually every price point. How do the Antonio Melani Carolies compare to other options on the market?

Compared to luxury designer versions (which can run $500+), the Carolies offer similar quality materials and construction at a significantly lower price point. While they may lack some of the brand prestige of designer options, the craftsmanship is competitive with sandals costing twice as much.

Against mid-range department store brands, the Carolies generally offer superior leather quality and more thoughtful comfort features. The cushioned footbed and perfectly balanced wedge set them apart from many similarly priced alternatives that prioritize appearance over wearability.

When compared to budget-friendly fast fashion versions (typically under $50), the difference becomes more pronounced. The durability alone makes the Carolies a better value proposition despite the higher initial investment. While you might replace cheaper versions annually, the Carolies can easily last 3-5 years with proper care.

The most direct competitors are other premium comfort brands like Gentle Souls, Pikolinos, or certain styles from Clarks. Here, the Carolies hold their own with comparable comfort features but often with a more fashion-forward design that doesn’t scream “comfort shoe” visually.

What truly sets the Antonio Melani Carolie apart is the specific combination of the fisherman upper with the espadrille wedge—many alternatives offer either one feature or the other, but rarely both executed so well together. This unique pairing creates a silhouette that’s both distinctive and versatile.

Value Assessment: Are They Worth the Investment?

At a retail price typically between $120-$150 (depending on sales and promotions), the Antonio Melani Carolie Espadrille Platform Wedge Fisherman Sandals represent a significant investment compared to budget footwear options. Are they worth it? Let me break down the value proposition:

In terms of cost per wear, these sandals offer exceptional value if you live in a climate with extended warm seasons or travel frequently to warm destinations. During summer months, I wear mine at least 3-4 times per week, which quickly brings the per-wear cost down to reasonable levels. After three seasons of heavy use, my original black pair has cost me less than $1 per wear—and they’re still going strong.

The versatility factor significantly boosts their value. Unlike specialized footwear that only works for specific occasions, the Carolies can replace multiple pairs of sandals in your wardrobe. They’ve eliminated my need for separate casual sandals, dressy heeled options, and vacation-specific footwear, effectively condensing three potential purchases into one.

From a quality and longevity perspective, these sandals represent a wise investment. The premium materials and construction have allowed mine to maintain both their appearance and comfort through multiple seasons, while cheaper alternatives I’ve purchased in the past rarely survive a single summer without significant deterioration.

Comfort value is another important consideration. The ability to wear these for extended periods without pain means I actually use them regularly, unlike many “occasion shoes” that sit in my closet because they’re too uncomfortable for practical use. The real-world wearability ensures you’ll get your money’s worth rather than having an expensive decoration for your shoe shelf.

For those concerned about the price point, I’ve noticed that Dillard’s occasionally includes these in their seasonal sales, where you might find them for 25-30% off. While they rarely make it to the deep discount racks, patient shoppers who don’t need them immediately might score a better deal by watching for promotions.

Final Thoughts: Why I’m Still Wearing Mine Three Summers Later

After spending extensive time with the Antonio Melani Carolie Espadrille Platform Wedge Fisherman Sandals, I can confidently say they’ve earned their place as a staple in my warm-weather wardrobe. What began as an impulsive purchase has become one of my most reliable and beloved footwear investments.

What impresses me most is how these sandals have transcended trends. While fashion has cycled through numerous sandal styles since I purchased my first pair, the Carolies continue to look current and receive compliments. The thoughtful combination of classic elements with contemporary proportions has created something with staying power—a rare quality in today’s fast-fashion landscape.

The versatility continues to surprise me. Just when I think I’ve explored all possible outfit combinations, I discover another way to style them that feels fresh and exciting. They’ve traveled with me across multiple continents, dressed me for countless summer events, and carried me comfortably through workdays and weekends alike.

Of course, no product is perfect. If I could change anything about the Carolie sandals, I might wish for a slightly wider range of colors each season and perhaps the addition of explicitly marked wide-width options for those who need them. But these are minor quibbles about a product that exceeds expectations in most areas.

For anyone considering adding these sandals to their collection, my advice is to view them as an investment in both style and comfort. The initial price point may be higher than impulse-purchase footwear, but the combination of quality, versatility, and enduring design makes them a worthwhile addition to any wardrobe.

If you value footwear that doesn’t force you to choose between looking good and feeling good, the Antonio Melani Carolie Espadrille Platform Wedge Fisherman Sandals deserve your serious consideration. Three summers in, I’m still discovering new reasons to love mine—and isn’t that the true hallmark of a worthwhile purchase?